Safe City

Safe City

Identification of Factors Affecting the Identity-Possessing of Building Facades in Historical Pathways(Case Study: Ghamat Bayat Street, Zanjan, Iran)1

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 Ph.D. Student, Department of Architecture, Zanjan Branch, Islamic Azad University, Zanjan, Iran
2 Assistant Professor, Department of Architecture, Zanjan Branch, Islamic Azad University, Zanjan, Iran
3 Assistant Professor, Department of Urban Planning, Zanjan Branch, Islamic Azad University, Zanjan, Iran
Abstract
Considering the importance of the identity of urban facades and despite the elaborations made on this concept
in theoretical and management communities, observations indicate that deviation from desirable facades is
still large in practice. Emphasizing the necessity of defining identities for facades in historical neighborhoods,
the present research seeks to identify the factors affecting the improved identity of the street landscape and
view. In this work, Ghamat Bayat Street, a newly constructed pathway in the central historical context of
Zanjan, Iran was considered as a case study. This is an applied research where data collection was performed
through library studies coupled with filed observations and surveys. The research method is a mix of
qualitative and quantitative procedures (i.e., mixed analytics), where quantitative data analysis was performed
in SPSS software. Statistical population of the research was composed of residents of Zeynabieh
Neighborhood of Zanjan, who made up a population of 578 individuals, of whom 230 individuals were
selected to form a statistical sample. Upon extracting the components of identity in facades along the urban
pathways out of theoretical foundations, the research variables were classified under three classes of
“physical”, “visual”, and “semantic” indices. Investigation of these variables along the studied street showed
that, from the Zeynabieh Neighborhood residents’ point of view, the visual (score: 3.610) and semantic
(score: 2.592) indices impose the largest and smallest contributions to improved quality of landscape in this
street, respectively. Focusing on the components, the highest and lowest impacts on the identity of facades
were found to be those of “balance and symmetry” and “unity/plurality” components with average scores of
3.73 and 2.86, respectively. Findings of this research indicate the necessity of paying attention to the three
primary dimensions of identity simultaneously. It was further figured out that, in the design and organization
of street landscapes in historical contexts, one must consider the existing physical basis and consistency of
different parts, avoid visual disturbance of walls, increase readability of spatial organization and social
interactions across public areas by formulating communal activities, identify local distinctions between the
considered street and the neighboring pathways followed by emphasizing and reinforcing these distinctions,
so as to realize the objectives of this research. Moreover, implementation of traditional construction methods
by means of locally available construction materials tends to establish a physical association between the
street and the precious surrounding urban context, harmonizing the new constructions with the old ones,
which ends up representing the urban identity along the considered street.
Keywords

[46] Carmona, Mattew; Heath.Tim; Oc. Taner; Tiestess. Stive (2003). Public place and urban space.
Architectural press, London.
[47] Cullen, G. (1961). Townscape. London: The Architectural Press.
[48] Deilmann, H., Bickenabach, G. and Pfeiffer, H. (1983). Living in Cities, Zurich.
[49] Jennath, K.A. & Nidhish, P. (2016). Aesthetic judgement and visual impact of architectural forms: a
study of library buildings. Procedia Technology, (24), 1808–1818.
[50] Lang, J. (1984). Formal aesthetics and visual perception: questions architects ask. Visual Arts
Research, 10(1), 66-73.
[51] Lynch, K. (1985); Site Planning; MIT, Cambridge, Mass.
[52] Swaffield, S. (2005). Landscape as A Way of Knowing the World. In: Harvey, S., Fieldhouse, Ken,
Hopkins, John (Ed.) The Cultured Landscape; Designing The Environment in The 21st Century.
Routledge.
[53] Utaberta, N., Jalali, A. H., Johar, S., Surat, M. & Che-Ani, A. I. (2012). Building Facade Study in
Lahijan City, Iran: The Impact of Facade's Visual Elements on Historical Image. International
Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences, 6(7), 1839-1844