Safe City

Safe City

Vulnerability assessment of dilapidated structures with a passive defense approach using the IHWP method (case study of Khobakht neighborhood)

Document Type : Original Article

Author
Department of Urban Planning, Faculty of Architecture and Urban Planning, Pars University, Tehran, Iran
Abstract
 Introduction
Urban deterioration is a growing concern in many developing cities, where aging infrastructure, dense populations, and inadequate planning converge to create vulnerable environments. In Iran, deteriorated urban fabrics—often characterized by narrow alleys, low structural integrity, and limited access to emergency services—pose significant risks in the face of natural disasters, socio-political instability, and military threats. This study focuses on the Khoubakht neighborhood in Tehran, applying the Integrated Hazard Weighting and Prioritization (IHWP) method within the framework of passive defense to evaluate its vulnerability. Passive defense, a strategic concept rooted in minimizing damage without active combat, offers a valuable lens for assessing urban resilience and guiding sustainable redevelopment.
Methodology and Analytical Framework
The research employs the IHWP method, which integrates multiple hazard dimensions—physical, social, economic, and infrastructural—into a weighted scoring system. The methodology unfolds in several stages:

Data Collection: Spatial and demographic data were gathered from municipal archives, satellite imagery, and field surveys. Key indicators included building age, structural type, population density, road accessibility, and proximity to critical infrastructure.
Hazard Identification: Potential threats were categorized into natural (e.g., earthquakes), technological (e.g., gas leaks), and military (e.g., aerial bombardment).
Weighting and Prioritization: Each hazard was assigned a weight based on its likelihood and potential impact. Vulnerability scores were calculated for each urban block using GIS-based spatial analysis.
Passive Defense Criteria: The analysis incorporated principles such as decentralization, redundancy, concealment, and structural reinforcement to assess how well the neighborhood aligns with passive defense standards.

Data Analysis and Findings
The IHWP model revealed several critical insights:

Structural Vulnerability: Over 70% of buildings in Khoubakht are older than 40 years, with unreinforced masonry and poor seismic resistance. These structures scored high in vulnerability to both natural and military threats.
Access and Mobility: The neighborhood suffers from limited road width and dead-end alleys, severely restricting emergency response and evacuation capabilities. This factor significantly increased the vulnerability index.
Population Density: With an average of 350 people per hectare, Khoubakht exceeds safe density thresholds, amplifying risks in crisis scenarios.
Infrastructure Exposure: The proximity of gas pipelines, electrical substations, and water mains to residential zones creates compounded risks in the event of explosions or sabotage.
Passive Defense Deficiencies: The neighborhood lacks decentralization of services, has minimal structural concealment, and shows no evidence of reinforced shelters or escape routes.

Results
The final IHWP vulnerability score placed Khoubakht in the “high-risk” category, with a composite index of 0.78 (on a scale of 0 to 1). Key contributors to this score included:

High structural fragility (weight: 0.30)
Poor accessibility (weight: 0.25)
Dense population (weight: 0.15)
Infrastructure exposure (weight: 0.20)
Lack of passive defense features (weight: 0.10)

The spatial distribution map generated through GIS highlighted several “hot zones” where vulnerability was most acute, particularly in the southern and central blocks of the neighborhood.
Conclusion and Recommendations
The study concludes that Khoubakht neighborhood is critically vulnerable and requires immediate intervention. Recommendations include:

Structural Retrofitting: Reinforce existing buildings with seismic-resistant materials and techniques.
Urban Reconfiguration: Redesign road networks to improve access and reduce bottlenecks.
Decentralization of Services: Relocate critical infrastructure to reduce exposure and enhance redundancy.
Passive Defense Integration: Introduce concealed shelters, escape routes, and reinforced nodes in urban planning.
Community Engagement: Educate residents on emergency protocols and involve them in participatory planning.

This research demonstrates the utility of combining IHWP methodology with passive defense principles to produce a nuanced, actionable vulnerability assessment. The findings can inform municipal policy, disaster preparedness strategies, and long-term urban renewal programs in Tehran and similar contexts.
 
Keywords

[1] Abazarlou, Sajjad, (6518). Master Thesis, "Assessing the Vulnerability of the City with a Passive
Defense Approach with Fuzzy Logic", Supervisor: Kioumars Habibi, Islamic Azad University of
Tehran Markaz, Department of Urban Planning.(in Persian)
[2] Abazarlou, Sajjad, Baghersad, Mansour, Poori Rahim, Ali Akbar (2016), Identifying
hazards and modeling the vulnerability of cities with a passive defense approach,
Publications of the Iranian Scientific Association of Passive Defense, First Edition, Tehran.
(in Persian).
[3] Alikhani, Arezoo, Barzegar Befrooi, Akram, Noorollahi, Haniyeh (6511), Presenting a
Comprehensive Assessment Model of Vulnerability of Urban Areas by Separating the
Layers of the City with Passive Defense Approach, Journal of Crisis Management, Volume
8, Number 6, Number 12, pp. .42-88. (in Persian).
[4] Atai, Hassan (6514), assessing the vulnerability of civilian airports in the country against threats and
providing solutions to reduce vulnerability, master's thesis, Malik Ashtar University of Technology,
Tehran, (in Persian).
[5] Bakel, N (2000), "Security risk assessment: Applying the concepts of fuzzy logic", Journal
of Hazardous Materials 173, 258–264.
[6] Bull Kamanga, R., S. Sturm, J. Kiefer, M. Bondelind, J. Åström, A. Lindhe, I. Machenbach,
E. Melin, T. Thorsen, B. Eikebrokk, C. Niewersch, D. Kirchner, F. Kozisek, D. Weyessa
Gari, and C. Swartz .(2003). "Identification and description of hazards for water supply
systems ", A catalogue of today’s hazards and possible future hazards, TECHNEAU.
[7] Chunliang Xiu, Lin Cheng, Wei Song, Wei Wu (2012). Vulnerability of large city and its
implication in urban planning: A perspective of intra-urban structure, Chinese Geographical
Science, Volume 21, Issue 2, pp 204–210
[8] Farzam Shad, Mustafa, Araqi Zadeh, Mojtabi. (6511). Basics of safe city planning and design from the
point of view of passive defense, Alam Afarin Publications. (in Persian).
[9] FathiRashid, Ali, golizadeh, elham (6558), passive defense in urban decay structures, Safe Society
Conference, Tehran Municipality (in Persian).
[10]Ghanbari Nasab, Ali, Ghale Asl, Nouri, Hamed, Aghaghnizadeh, Jahan, Ranjbar, Firooz
(2020), Assessing the vulnerability of urban worn-out structures from the perspective of
passive defense using hierarchical analysis method Case study: Ardabil, Journal of Crisis
Management , Volume 9, Special Issue of Passive Defense Week, pp: 98-85. (in Persian).
[11] Habibi, Kiyomarth, Pourahmad, Ahmad, Meshkini, Abolfazl, Asgari, Ali and Saeed Nazari-Adli,
(6555). "Determining effective construction factors in the vulnerability of the old urban fabric of
Zanjan using GIS and FUZZY LOGIC" Fine Arts, No. 88, pp: .82-65. (in Persian).
[12]Handmer, L. (2002). "The Changing Nature of Risks and Hazard". Chapter 1, in American
Hazardscapes: The Regionalization of Hazards and Disasters. Washington, DC: Joseph
Henry Press.
[13] Hosseini, Seyyed Behshid. (6551), general criteria in the design of public buildings in the city, Abid
Publishing House, Tehran (in Persian).
[14] Jalali Farahani, Gholamreza (6511). An introduction to the method and model of estimating threats in
passive defense, Institute of Printing and Publishing of Imam Hossein University. (in Persian).
[15]Jamshidi, Zahra, Radan, Mohammad Yaser, Nekouei, Mohammad Ali (6565), Passive
Defense Considerations in Designing Special Bridges to Continue Service in Crisis, Journal
of Crisis Management, Volume 1, Number 1- Serial Number 15, pp: 18- 28. (in Persian).
[16] Kamran, Hassan, Moradi, Morteza, Hosseini Amini, Hassan (6516), Evaluation of the old fabric of
cities based on non-active defense principles, Urban Management Studies, Volume 4( 16consecutive), 
pp: .18-1 (in Persian).
[17] Kamyabi, Saeed, Seyed Alipour, Seyed Khalil, Mir Emadi, Ebrahim. (6514). Evaluation of the safety
of urban space with emphasis on passive defense indicators using AHP and TOPSIS method, a case
study: Semnan city, Scientific and Promotional Quarterly of Passive Defense, No. 1( 61series), pp. -11
56. (in Persian).
[18] Khalilabad kalantari, Hossein, Abazarlu, Sajjad, abazarlou, Heydari, Ali Akbar (6566), identifying the
vulnerability process of cities with passive defense approach, University of Art, Tehran (in Persian).
[19]Minami, Masaaki et al. (2013)Street Network Planning For Disaster Prevention Against
Street Blockade, Proceedings of the Eastern Asia Society for Transportation Studies, Vol.4,
October, 2008, Page 1750-1756.
[20]Rashed, K and Weeks, J. (2019)”Assessing vulnerability to earthquake hazards through
spatial multicriteria analysis of urban areas”, International Journal of Geographic
Information Science Vol. 17, no. 6: 547-576.
[21] Sanei, Priya, Elah Bakhshi (6511), evaluation of the worn-out fabric of cities based on non-active
defense considerations, National Conference on worn-out and historical urban fabrics, Ministry of
Science, Research and Technology, Tehran (in Persian).
[22] Shamsai Zafarqandi, Fathollah (6515). Architectural form and its role in reducing blast wave effects.
Proceedings of the first conference on architecture and urban planning from the point of view of
passive defense. Malik Ashtar University of Technology. (in Persian).
[23]Snaider .B, House of Representatives. (2004). "Comprehensive Risk Assessments and
Stronger Internal Controls Needed to Help Inform TSA Resource Allocation", Report to the
Chairman,
[24]Zarei, Gholamreza, Abazarlou, Sajjad (6511), Investigating the Vulnerability of Cities with
Passive Defense Approach Using IHWP and GIS - Case Study of Greater Tehran